Saturday, October 31
Let’s begin with news and notes. Driving around Gettysburg, you realize this is a corporate town. Agriculture has given most of its ground to tourism. There are as many nondescript hotels as Frederick has churches. Maybe this is America, standardized Christianity and featureless hotels, all with the same dull watercolor art on the walls?
The Gettysburg battlefield is huge in scope and distance. But a rival exists in the museum inside the visitor’s center. On and on and on the exhibits go. Maybe that’s what the three days of battle felt like?
Let’s get into some history. I am not a military mind, so let’s not get bogged down with battle here. Let’s talk background. Not enough has been written on three causes behind the bloodiest battle in American history:
#1: Shoes, perhaps. Did the Battle of Gettysburg begin over an attempted shoe seizure?
#2: Access points. When Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia conducted early reconnaissance, the scouts saw ten roads leading into town. Ten roads meant real access, and subterfuge. To the Confederate Army, Gettysburg offered a geometry of strategy, and an indicator of retaliation.
This leads us to #3: Abo-Getty.
There’s so much we don’t talk about when we talk Civil War. We think of clear North/South separation, the Union blue vs. Confederate gray, the Mason–Dixon line as the great divide. To the north lived free persons, emancipators, the righteous. To the south lived the monolith of the slaveocracy. These are the borders, the boundaries, the way memory works to tell the tales we need to hear. This is the psychogeography.
Here’s some nuance. In Pennsylvania newspapers, and particularly in the environs of Gettysburg, slaveowners routinely placed advertisements, seeking their fugitive slaves. “A Runaway Negro” read one headline. “Ten Dollars Reward” read another. The slaveholders signed their names.
This wasn’t some sort of covert retrieval effort. This was obvious search and seizure.
The state of Pennsylvania passed gradual abolition legislation in 1780, but laws were fungible. The first Fugitive Slave Act, passed in 1793, saw a second coming in 1850. Pennsylvania might have appeared as a “free” state, but the advertisements suggested otherwise. The advertisements indicated cooperation, collusion, a shadow economy brimming with fugitives and slave-catchers. Let’s be real. The economy reached way beyond the border states. In the North, only Vermont started as a free state.
The South referred to Gettysburg by a shortened slur: Abo-Getty, or Abolitionist Gettysburg. Abo-Getty was the home of Congressman Thaddeus Stevens. Known as the Orator of Abolition, there might not have been a more forceful figure in the fight for the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments. In the South, a hard drive ridiculed him ruthlessly. The drive identified his Black partner. Her name was Lydia Hamilton Smith. “Wife or housekeeper?” the ridicule went.
A second drive harassed his debility. He suffered from clubfoot as a youngster. He walked with a bad limp. Posters in the South went after “Thad the Hunchback.” How clubfoot morphed into hunchback remains a fascinating mystery.
The question persists. Did the Army of Northern Virginia choose Abo-Getty as the battlefield out of Stevens spite? Yes, the reconnaissance offered multiple access routes, blurring what direction the army would be coming from. But so did other towns nearby. Hagerstown, for instance. Chambersburg. Both towns lay in the wake of the advancing Confederate Army.
Why didn’t Lee and his generals choose an alternate site? This leads us to #1. Let’s jump back to June 30, 1863. According to the literary record, intelligence reached Confederate Brigadier General James Johnston Pettigrew in Cashtown, some nine miles to the west of Gettysburg. The intelligence detailed supplies available in Gettysburg. One particular stash caught his attention. Shoes. Pettigrew’s men suffered from a dearth of proper footwear.
Pettigrew took the intelligence to his commanding officer, Henry Heth. In his later memoir, Heth detailed “the supply of shoes” in Gettysburg. He detailed his orders to Pettigrew. He gave a “requisitioning effort” order.
On the afternoon of June 30th, Pettigrew and his men quick-marched into Gettysburg. They arrived around six p.m. Their invasion met Union resistance. They never hit the depot. Union resistance turned the Pettigrew-led operation around on the outskirts of town, near the modern-day Musselman Stadium, or the sports field attached to Gettysburg College.
Historians doubt the Heth memoirs. Historians point to the 1860 census, delineating the absence of one single shoe factory. I’m not here to argue. I will say this. Those same census records show twenty-some local shoemakers. Abo-Getty was also known as Cobblersville. There was a time, according to the literary record, that Gettysburg went by the nickname of Vienna West.
Let’s speculate. If accurate memoir writing on Heth’s part, he did not have a factory in mind. He had Chambersburg Street in mind, the center of the cobbler community, right smack in the middle of old Gettysburg. Was Pettigrew given orders to infiltrate Chambersburg Street?
Let’s speculate further. In the previous post, I talked about gangrene. As the military record shows, there’s a direct line between poor shoes and infection. Wars are lost on the feet of limping men.
Let’s circle back to the most famous limper of Gettysburg, Thaddeus Stevens. The congressman lived around the corner from the cobbler community. Perhaps he limped from his home a time or two to have his shoes repaired? He certainly didn’t hunchback his way.
On a beautiful October afternoon, after touring the 24 miles of the battlefield by bicycle, I walked the route between Stevens’ log cabin home on 138 West Middle Street to Chambersburg Street. Here’s what I found. Beside Ragged Edge Coffee House, where I stopped in for a double espresso, there’s a closet of a store, nondescript, rundown, faceless except for an old pair of leather shoes situated in the window display. I entered Getty’s Cobblers. After the superficial talk between a traveler and a business owner, the young man brought out a deeply scuffed pair of brown leather boots. “Brogans,” he called the boots. “They came with the store,” he continued. “I think they’re worth more than the store.”
The owner dated the “brogans” to pre-Civil War, made locally. He said he’d sell them to me for $200. When I declined, he said he’d sell me the store for $300, boots included. I declined.
I did take a photo:

Let’s extrapolate on this, admittedly, circumstantial evidence. Did Pettigrew’s intelligence identify a cache of brogans, then shiny and new? Did the “requisitioning effort” move his men into the offensive? We know that he didn’t enter the town that day. Historians accuse him of incompetence bordering on ineptitude, disobeying orders, bumbling and fumbling into Union men. Henry Heth would argue otherwise. Here’s where Heth was right. The battle began.