And Darkness Comes: A rumination
I am sitting beside the Mary Thompson House on Seminary Ridge, high ground on the Gettysburg battlefield. Mary Thompson was a 69-year-old twice-widow when the war entered her home. In Pennsylvania at that time, women couldn’t own property. We don’t talk about that divide when we talk Civil War. We don’t talk about the need for a savior, Congressman Thaddeus Stevens in this case, coming to her rescue. Stevens purchased the small stone house for Thompson. He never lived there. Stevens was a key voice of abolition, but let’s recognize that the patriarchy must be served.
When the Army of Northern Virginia came to town, General Lee requisitioned the Mary Thompson House to serve as his headquarters. Located on top of Seminary Ridge high above the Chambersburg Pike, the advantage was obvious. Lee gained panoramic sightlines. With field glasses, he could see all the way to Virginia, and to Harrisburg.
The historical record recognizes the nursing acumen of Mary Thompson, as she tended to the injured surrounding her home. Was Mary Thompson an abolitionist, a believer in the slaveocracy, or someone who blurred the lines? We don’t talk about her politics when we talk Civil War. We talk about her care, tending to the injured and the dying.
Let’s talk more about care. Personnel from both the North and the South treated the wounded on the other side. Sometimes the personnel was a doctor or a nurse, a farmer or a priest. Crossing boundary lines isn’t something we talk about these days.
I have come to Seminary Ridge by bicycle to follow what Lee saw through his field glasses. Lee, of course, didn’t come by bicycle. He came on top of his favorite horse, Traveller. When Traveller died, a year after Lee, his remains went inside the Lee Family crypt. If you visit Washington and Lee University, you can visit the remains of the horse.
On top of Seminary Ridge, trying to get inside Lee’s reconnaissance brain, something unexpected happens to me. I want to be honest here. I am overcome by emotion. The scope of this post then changes, radically. Let me try to work my way through it, in as brief a description as I can. Maybe not the 272 words of Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address, delivered at the national cemetery less than a mile to the east, visible from the ridge, but hopefully something concise and meaningful. This is going to be a rumination, raw and unfiltered.
Everything ends. We know this to be a basic biological trait. Darkness comes. With darkness in mind, let’s think about these soldiers. Not Lee, or Longstreet, or even the brave Pickett. Let’s think about the soldier in the field and, specifically, let’s focus on the man fighting for the Confederacy. For this swing at understanding, let’s pass over the reasons for the war. That might sound hard. I am an American very much in pain over our slaver roots, and how strong they remain. Vice President of the Confederacy, Alexander Stephens, based the “cornerstone” of the conflict on a “great truth.” “The negro,” he said, “is not equal to the white man.” “Slavery,” he continued, “subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition.”
Let’s try to put those words aside, if we can, and let’s talk about advances made and losses endured during the mud and muddle of three days of heavy fighting. I feel the burden of a question. What compels a man to push against entrenched positions? In the moment of a run across an open field, with the enemy owning the high ground and carbines loaded and aimed, did these soldiers know their deaths loomed? If not, when did it hit them? When they came up against the wall of Union firepower? When they felt their comrades fall beside them? What could they see? What could they hear? Have we talked enough about the boom of individual heartbeats, reverberating through the body, a kind of fear circulation? Maybe these men could only hear the pounding of their heartbeats in their ears?
Recently, I have developed the fear of my own death. Is this a mid-life crisis? I have done something risky. I have moved away from my home of twenty years. I now have no home. Why? The answer isn’t something we talk about. I didn’t want to die in that apartment. I don’t know where I want to die, but I know this. Gettysburg is a vulnerable place for those who fear death.
Gettysburg is an exposure, with death in the soil all around. Maybe that’s why I’ve bicycled to Seminary Ridge, to Mary Thompson’s House, to Lee’s headquarters, with the national cemetery in sight? Gettysburg exposed Lee. I feel exposed.
I will be 59 years old in a few days. These soldiers were young, ages 18-35. Their lives were in front of them. And, yet, behind them. Days after Gettysburg, I will visit Hollywood Cemetery in Richmond. There is a mass grave there. It’s not near the James River side of the cemetery. Presidents Monroe, Tyler, and Jeff Davis have views of the James. The mass grave has no views. Three thousand Confederate soldiers in that grave died at Gettysburg. The numbers are an estimate. Originally, they were buried where they fell. They were buried by the good people of Gettysburg in the immediate aftermath of battle. They would be exhumed and reinterred some ten years later. It’s a terrifying story. Hollywood can be a vulnerable place for those who fear death.
A further question demands something of me here at Seminary Ridge. Did these men who died here believe they could win? Another question might be: Is victory worth death? Another question might be: What would I say to a dead Confederate soldier?
I think I would ask about courage. I think I would ask about the ground, what it’s like to fall from a bullet, what it’s like to lose consciousness, what it’s like not to breathe. I think I would ask about regret. What does it feel like when courage ends in regret?
At the end of the battle, as the Confederacy made for Virginia, General Lee again and again took the blame for the staggering losses at Gettysburg. Loss is not death. Failure is not death. What links us, the Confederate soldier at Gettysburg perhaps fighting for the superiority of his race, and a middle-aged man of the 21st century, writing to understand? Perhaps courage. Perhaps regret. Gettysburg offers a raw connection. Maybe this is something Lincoln understood when he came to consecrate the cemetery in November 1863? He said, “The world will little note, nor long remember, what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here.”
What they did here was memorable. They attacked, and they fell, and the darkness came, and the memory entered the soil. And some 160 years later, the memory forces the question. What does it feel like when courage ends in regret?
Honest, beautiful and emotionally moving piece.
LikeLike